| Phenton Metcalf (1835 - 1915) |
|
| Mary Peele Whitson (1841 - 1917) |
| Elroy E. Cottingham | Vinnie Ruth Metcalf |
| b. d. bur. occ. rel. Flags. |
b. 14 Jul 1871, Boone Co, Kentucky d. 8 Feb 1953, Van Wert County, Ohio bur. occ. rel. Flags. |
| Cottingham Cottingham Grace Cottingham Edythe C. Cottingham Florence Cottingham |