| James D. Mullin (1827 - 1895) |
|
| Sarah Ann Claxton (1831 - 1897) |
| Andrew Thomas Shafer | Arvina Mullin |
| b. 3 Feb 1857, Elk Creek, Spencer, Kentucky d. 17 Apr 1920, Elk Creek, Spencer, Kentucky bur. occ. rel. Flags. |
b. 1861, Kentucky d. abt 1950, Indiana bur. occ. rel. Flags. |
| Spouses: 1, 2 |
| Frank Marion Shafer |